The Darkest Files

Steam Reviews

Read all reviews on Steam

• Recommended Posted July 31, 2025 on Steam The Darkest Files is a gripping courtroom sim in which you investigate Nazi war crimes. My only issue is there are only two cases.
• Recommended Posted December 28, 2025 on Steam A video game done right. Idea inspires the art, art serves the narrative, and narrative empowers the gameplay. Each and every dialog is voiced, and the job of voice actors is outstanding. Authors do not cheap out on anything important in such a game. Artstyle, voice actors, and document design - all of this is done with great care and respect for the players. Prosecution ceses itself are grounded and layered. It serves right for immersion, each new witness brings new perspective. The process makes you excited for every new paper you request from your paralegal because every document adds up or significantly shifts your own idea of what really happened. The detective part is challenging but not frustrating. The process manages to make you feel smart without assuming you are dumb. A rare quality among detective mechanics. The game strikes the right balance between making a player a passionate young prosecutor and communicating the message behind the story.
• Recommended Posted August 26, 2025 on Steam A great detective game with a deeply moving and important story about fascism, culpability, and memory. Essential for anyone who believes games can have serious artistic merit, and an important work for our present age. Never again
• Recommended Posted July 21, 2025 on Steam The game mixes investigation, dialogue choices, evidence analysis, and courtroom storytelling. You gather testimonies, review old documents, and reconstruct events from WWII atrocities. These are not fantasy crimes—they’re based on real historical cases, including war crimes committed at concentration camps and mass executions. It’s important to note that while these crimes are based on true events, the names of those involved were changed. The only exception is Fritz Bauer, who investigated cases of post-war crimes in Germany. The player takes control of a young prosecutor, Esther Katz. She joins Bauer’s group in solving cases that are left unnoticed by the people of Germany. They smartly point out in the beginning that most of the judges and officers didn’t get involved in solving these cases because they were also with the Nazi party at the time. Now, it’s up to Bauer’s group to bring justice and give a sense of peace to the victims. With a good chunk of investigation games, players will look over a couple of documents. Like a lot of great detective games, The Darkest Files goes all the way through this aspect. Not only are players looking into pages of notes, but they are also interviewing people and going through court cases. The amount of detail here is astounding, and players could easily get lost in the amount of information present. The art style for [b]The Darkest Files[/b] matches the gameplay as it’s very noir-inspired. When the player walks into the building for the first time, it feels like they’ve been transported into some of the best film noirs from the 1930s. It’s dripping with atmosphere, and gamers can feel the long hours at work in the building just by looking at it. The shadows in this game are phenomenal and stylized in the best way. The game does not shy away from its dark subject matter and treats the material with sobering seriousness. You learn not only about the crimes of the Nazi regime but also about the legal and moral struggles of post-war Germany. Interviews and evidence analysis are engaging, encouraging players to think critically and weigh inconsistencies. While atmospheric, the gameplay can feel linear. You often know what conclusion the game wants you to reach. The game isn’t for casual entertainment—it’s grim, challenging, and morally weighty. It aims to provoke reflection rather than excitement. If you're looking for a detective story with action, this isn’t it. But if you're interested in historical justice and exploring how societies confront their darkest moments, it’s compelling. [b]The Darkest Files[/b] is a powerful blend of history, narrative, and investigation. It’s not perfect in its execution, but its importance and integrity make it stand out. It’s less a game in the traditional sense and more of an interactive memorial, asking you to think deeply about accountability and remembrance. [h1]7/10[/h1] DISASTER | BAD | MEDIOCRE | OKAY | [b][u]GOOD[/u][/b] | GREAT |AMAZING| MASTERPIECE [quote] Reviewed on: Win11 Home 64-bit, Intel i5-11600K, GeForce RTX 3060 Ti 8GB TUF, 32GB DDR4-3600 RAM, 2 x Kingston NV1 1TB M.2 NVMe SSD, Internet Broadband 1000/1000 Mbit[/quote] [quote] If you like this review, then please consider giving it a thumbs up. I've also reviewed other games that you might find interesting. If so please follow [u][url=https://store.steampowered.com/curator/27418263/] Top of the Chart.[/url][/u]
• Recommended Posted December 23, 2025 on Steam Creating a narrative game about Nazi Germany requires the courage to confront the darkest chapters of a country’s past. By doing so, The Darkest Files joins a list of courageous works of art that did the same in a political climate where looking back on mistakes is not appreciated. What makes this especially challenging for games is the need to strike a careful balance between treating history with the respect it deserves and offering engaging gameplay. The Darkest Files succeeds at this in an outstanding way. The vast majority of World War II games focus on shooting Nazis, operating on the assumption that evil has a clear and unmistakable face. The Darkest Files takes a fundamentally different approach that seems to be inspired by the work of Hannah Arendt. Playing as novice prosecutor Esther Katz, you investigate crimes from the Nazi past through interrogations and archival research, much like in a detective game. Although the defendants are not high-ranking Nazis, they are ordinary people, such as loyal civil servants and jealous neighbors. The puzzle pieces come together in the courtroom, where each chapter of the game builds toward its conclusions. Even more so than in Paintbucket Games’ previous title, Through the Darkest of Times, this design results not only in addictive gameplay that culminates in a cinematic courtroom climax, but also in a powerful educational experience. The game teaches the player about the atrocities committed in Nazi Germany and, crucially, about the social and personal mechanisms that led ordinary people to commit these crimes. At a time when authoritarianism and nationalism are once again on the rise, games like The Darkest Files feel urgently necessary. They help educate a new generation about the darkness humans are capable of under the right circumstances, and about why justice must prevail, even when a country is eager to move on and look only toward the future. In doing so, The Darkest Files pays a wonderful tribute to the rule of law and sets a new standard for narrative games. I'll be the first to buy the DLC if it ever comes out.
• Recommended Posted December 18, 2025 on Steam It feels weird to say I loved it, but I did. The theme means it's a rough go at times, but nothing's played for shock value. The investigation/interview mechanics are smooth and satisfying. There are three suggested difficulty presets, but you can adjust settings pretty granularly to make the parts you enjoy tougher and the parts you don't more forgiving. And it's just a beautiful, aesthetically consistent game all around. My main criticism is that it feels like a half a game. You do two cases, and then once you're comfortable with the flow and ready for something trickier, the game ends. I know the devs have said that the amount of research and work that went into making the cases meant they couldn't do more than two, but I really wish there more to this. I'd buy DLC cases for sure, but the game as is just feels incomplete.